I recently received a catalogue through the post from Adam’s, the Dublin-based auction house, announcing the latest auction on Tuesday 18th May, entitled The Great Famine.

Up for auction were 332 lots, including many letters from the archives of a firm of Dublin solicitors, Steward & Kinkaid, who acted as agents for a number of landlords and estates including:
Sligo: Lord Palmerstown, Col. Wingfield
Roscommon: the Marquess of Westmeath, Daniel Ferrell
Clare & Limerick: the Stratford Estate
Kilkenny & Carlow: the Frankfort Estates
Some of the letters relate directly to the Famine while others discuss affairs on the estate, relationships between tenants and various other themes. Because the archive was so large, the auctioneers had selected 150 letters to be sold separately. After reading the catalogue from cover to cover, and hoping I might win Saturday’s lotto, I reflected and thought that nice as it was for me or anyone else to have a chance to own a piece of history, it was a shame that the archive was to be broken up. (The papers had been bought in the late 1980s and early 1990s by a private individual).
For a start, any letters that might end up in private hands would be enjoyed by the owner, but would be difficult for researchers to know about or access. Then, because many of those who are interested in the Famine period are located outside Ireland the documents might end up spread across many different locations. These two factors would mean that the context of the letters would be lost. As any researcher knows, the value of such a collection of documents is not just in what can be gained from each document in isolation (though of course they may be interesting in themselves) but also in how they relate to each other. And then of course, collections of records from different estates might be compared to build up a comparison of what was happening in different areas. So while it might be interesting for an individual to purchase one of the letters, it might not be beneficial to the study of Irish history as a whole.
So, I was delighted to hear on the RTE news tonight that it has been decided that the collection will remain intact. The following note was posted on the Adam’s website:
‘Following intensive successful negotiations, with Kennys of Galway acting as intermediary, we are delighted to announce that the Stewart & Kincaid Famine Letters (Lots 1-147 incl in our May 18th Famine Sale) are to be kept together as a Collection and given to an important archive here in Ireland, where they will, in due course, be available for academic research.’
Some research has already been conducted into the papers by Desmond Norton at UCD who, it states on their website, originally acquired the papers. Meanwhile, many other interesting Irish lots are up for auction in the forthcoming Adam’s sale…
If you have any comments on this article or the issues raised in it, please leave a comment!